Listen here:
SUMMARY
If you’ve ever watched your child lose joy in a sport they once loved, this episode will hit close to home.
Christy-Faith and guest Jonathan Carone discuss how youth sports has slowly shifted from play to pressure. What used to be backyard games and simple fun has turned into rankings, money, identity, and adult expectations kids were never meant to carry.
This episode is not about blaming parents or coaches. It’s not anti-sports either (We love sports and competition!). It is about pausing long enough to ask what our kids actually need, and what really lasts after the last game is played.
SHOW SPONSORS
BJU Press Homeschool
- All in one or specific courses
- Biblical worldview
- Critical thinking
- Hands-on learning
The perfect balance of structure and flexibility. Visit BJU Press Homeschool.
Lovevery
The Reading Skill Set by Lovevery is a phonics-based program that follows the science of reading, but makes learning to read fun, motivating, and confidence-boosting, because it happens by playing games, then practicing with just-right-skill-level books.
- 98% of children improved their reading test scores in just 6 weeks!
Visit Lovevery.com today and use code CHRISTY10 to get 10% off
CTC Math
Try CTCMath’s adaptive, individualized online curriculum risk-free and see if CTCMath is the right fit for your family. Get 50% off plus a 12-month money back guarantee. Try CTC Math.
Azure Standard
Homeschool-family-owned company dedicated to providing affordable organic, natural, and non-gmo groceries, health, home, and garden products. Shop over 12,000 options to meet your needs as a health minded household.
All products vetted to be free of:
- Harmful preservatives
- Food colorings
- Chemicals
- Pesticides
Visit AzureStandard.com today and use code CHRISTYFAITH15 to get 15% off your first order.
🌟 SPECIAL GUEST
Jonathan Carone
🔗 http://www.healthysportsparents.com
The $40 Billion Youth Sports Machine // Jonathan Carone
A $40 billion industry is banking on us never doing the actual math. Meanwhile, who’s paying the price? Our kids.
Host: Christy-Faith, author of Homeschool Rising and founder of Thrive Homeschool Community
Guest: Jonathan Carone, founder of Healthy Sports Parents
Episode Summary
If you’ve ever wondered whether all the travel teams, tournaments, and expenses are really worth it, this episode will meet you right where you are.
In this honest and eye-opening conversation, Christy-Faith sits down with Jonathan Carone, a former Division I athletics professional and current youth sports advocate who’s been on every side of the game. From coaching high school baseball to parenting his own kids through rec leagues, Jonathan saw a moment on a sideline that changed everything: a dad yelling at his daughter until she cried. Instead of judgment, he felt empathy. Because without his own background and training, he knew he could have been that dad.
What follows is a deep dive into how youth sports became a $40 billion industry, why 70% of kids quit by age 13, and what the actual odds are of your child earning a D1 scholarship or going pro. Spoiler: the numbers might make you rethink everything.
But this episode isn’t about guilt. It’s about freedom. It’s about naming the tension every sports parent lives in and learning how to stay connected to your child’s heart through it all.
You’ll hear why parental insecurities show up on the sidelines, how “good job, now do it again” can quietly wound a child, and the only three things you should ever say in the car after a game.
Key Takeaways
- Youth sports shine a light on our deepest insecurities without us realizing it.
- Self-love and self-glory drive more of our sideline behavior than we’d like to admit.
- 70% of kids quit their sport by age 13. 98% are done by 18.
- Only 2.5% of high school varsity athletes will play Division I. Half of one percent will get scholarship money.
- Parenting in youth sports is a tension between being too competitive and too permissive. Neither extreme serves your child.
- Most of us are getting this wrong most of the time. And that’s okay.
- When we get it wrong, modeling repair and apology matters more than getting it right.
- Your child’s identity and yours should never be tied to a jersey or a sport.
Why This Matters
Many families are pouring thousands of dollars and countless hours into youth sports without ever stopping to ask why. The pressure is real—and it’s coming from everywhere. Coaches, culture, other parents, and sometimes our own unresolved stuff.
This episode gives you permission to step back and do the math. Not just financially, but emotionally. What is this costing your family? And more importantly, what is it costing your relationship with your child?
You are not a basketball mom. You are not a football dad. You are a human being who loves a child who enjoys playing a sport. That reframe changes everything.
Practical First Steps
Ask yourself why. Why is your child in this sport? Why at this level? What are you hoping for?
Do the math. Look at the real statistics on scholarships and professional sports before investing tens of thousands of dollars.
Live in the tension. Acknowledge that navigating youth sports is hard, and checking in regularly with your kids about how they’re feeling is essential.
Watch your words. Even well-meaning phrases like “good job, now do it again” can communicate that nothing is ever good enough.
Model repair. When you mess up on the sideline or in the car, apologize. Your kids are watching how you handle failure.
Say only three things after the game. “I loved watching you play. What do you want to listen to? Where do you want to eat?”
Resources Mentioned
Healthy Sports Parents – Jonathan Carone’s podcast and community
👉 healthysportsparents.com
The Weekend Playbook – Jonathan’s Friday newsletter with weekly tips for showing up differently at games
Raise Good Teammates Merch – T-shirts, hoodies, and hats to support Jonathan’s upcoming book
BJU Press Homeschool – Flexible structure with a biblical worldview
👉 bjupresshomeschool.com/christy
Azure Standard – Affordable, organic, natural groceries and household products 💰 Use code CHRISTYFAITH15 for 15% off your first order
👉 AzureStandard.com
Notable Quotes
“The first one is youth sports shine a light on all of our deepest insecurities without us realizing it.” – Jonathan Carone
“Every kid will play their last game at some point. 70% of kids, it’s by the time they’re 13. 98% of kids, it’s by the time they’re 18.” – Jonathan Carone
“Youth sports in America has been hijacked. What used to be kids playing in the backyard has become a $40 billion industry, and families are the ones paying.” – Christy-Faith
Share This Episode
Send this to a parent who’s knee-deep in travel ball and wondering if it’s all worth it. They might not know there’s another way to think about this. This episode could be the permission slip they need.
Join the Conversation
What’s your family’s relationship with youth sports right now? Share your story in the comments or tag Christy-Faith on Instagram.
Other Episodes for You
Behind the Screen: A Real Homeschool Day at My House
🔗 https://christy-faith.com/podcast/behind-the-screen-part-1-6-a-real-homeschool-day-at-my-house-nobodys-winning-awards/
The Secret to Making Childhood Memories
🔗 https://christy-faith.com/podcast/the-secret-to-making-childhood-memories/
You Can Start Homeschooling Anytime: Here’s Exactly How
🔗 https://christy-faith.com/podcast/you-can-start-homeschooling-anytime-heres-exactly-how/
