Listen here:
Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Amazon
Homeschool Testing: Why Standardized Tests Weren’t Designed for Your Family — and When to Use Them Anyway
Every spring, testing season arrives — and with it, a quiet spiral that hits homeschool moms harder than most people realize. When should homeschoolers use standardized testing? Is it even required where you live? And if your child’s scores come back lower than expected, does that mean you’re failing? These aren’t small questions. They sit at the intersection of law, philosophy, and the very personal choice you made when you decided to do education differently.
In this episode of The Christy-Faith Show — the podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously — homeschool expert Christy-Faith brings over 20 years of experience in education to the table, including years spent teaching SAT and ACT prep to hundreds of students and writing test prep curriculum. She helps homeschool families understand when standardized testing genuinely serves their child, when it doesn’t, and how to use it strategically rather than reflexively.
Why the Standardized Testing Ruler Doesn’t Fit Homeschoolers
Standardized testing for homeschoolers was never designed with your family in mind. These tests were built for public schools managing hundreds — sometimes thousands — of kids at once, where individual attention is mathematically impossible and statistical averages are the best anyone can do. They measure a narrow band of skills: recalling isolated facts, applying formulaic math procedures, and reading short passages under time pressure. That is not what most homeschoolers are doing at the kitchen table. And yet, every time a homeschool family measures their child against a public school scope and sequence, they’re picking up a ruler that was never built for the education they’re giving.
The philosophy baked into most standardized tests assumes all children should learn the same things at the same pace — that a child who hasn’t hit long division by the end of third grade is “behind.” Those are the exact assumptions most homeschool families rejected when they chose this path. A child on a different timeline isn’t behind. She’s on a different timeline. That distinction matters enormously, and Christy-Faith argues it’s the first thing every homeschool parent needs to internalize before they ever look at a test score.
When Homeschool Testing Actually Serves Your Family
Even if you reject the philosophy behind standardized testing, there are legitimate practical reasons to test — as long as the key word is strategic. Testing as a tool that serves your family is a very different thing than testing as a loyalty oath to a system you already left. Christy-Faith identifies four situations where testing earns its place: catching foundational gaps before they snowball (a child can appear to understand material during lessons while still being unable to apply it independently), fulfilling a state requirement, preparing a college-bound student for admissions (the test-optional wave is receding — MIT, Harvard, and Stanford are among schools returning to requiring or recommending scores), and getting an outside reference point when your objectivity as teacher-parent becomes difficult to maintain.
Research consistently shows that homeschool students score above the national average on standardized tests — meaning your college-bound child is walking into the testing room with a real advantage. That advantage is worth understanding and using intentionally, rather than ignoring because the tests themselves feel philosophically misaligned.
When to Skip Standardized Testing Entirely
For families not subject to a state requirement, there are clear situations where standardized testing doesn’t earn its place. In early childhood — under age seven or eight — formal testing produces unreliable results. Kids develop at wildly different rates in these years, and a low score at age six tells you almost nothing about long-term ability. What it reliably produces instead is anxiety, for both parent and child. Families using mastery-based or alternative approaches — Charlotte Mason, classical education in the early grammar stage, unschooling — are also often poor candidates for standardized testing, because the test may have zero overlap with their scope and sequence. A low score in a subject that simply hasn’t been covered yet isn’t a data point. It’s noise.
Christy-Faith also advises skipping testing when the results won’t change any decisions — because testing that doesn’t inform action is just a number to feel good or bad about. And during upheaval — a move, a health crisis, a new baby, grief — test performance is temporarily suppressed in ways that have nothing to do with what a child actually knows. Give your family breathing room. The tests will be there when life settles.
Which Standardized Test Is Best for Homeschoolers?
The right test depends entirely on what you need it to do. The Iowa Assessments are among the most widely used by homeschoolers, covering grades K–12 across reading, language arts, math, science, and social studies. Their strength is diagnostic detail — rather than just a percentile, you get a breakdown of specific skill areas, making the Iowa one of the few tests that helps you teach better, not just feel better or worse about a score. Note that it is timed. For children with test anxiety or attention challenges, the Stanford 10 is often the better fit — the online version through Seton Testing Services is untimed, widely accepted in most states, and requires no special credentials to administer. The CAT (California Achievement Test) is typically the most affordable and convenient option; a parent can administer it without credentials, and providers like Christian Liberty offer immediate results without waiting for mail-in scoring.
The MAP Growth test is computer-adaptive — it adjusts difficulty in real time based on each answer — producing an unusually precise picture of your child’s actual instructional level. It’s particularly valuable for identifying gifted learners or tracking growth over time, though it typically requires testing through a co-op or umbrella school and may not be accepted in all states. For classically educated students, the CLT (Classic Learning Test) deserves serious consideration: it uses passages from Aristotle, C.S. Lewis, and Frederick Douglass — the actual texts a classical student has been reading — and is accepted by over 300 colleges with more than $100 million in annual scholarships attached. Many classically educated homeschoolers score higher on the CLT than on the SAT or ACT, because for once the test reflects the education they actually received. For college-bound high schoolers preparing for the SAT or ACT, free standardized testing prep is available: Khan Academy offers official Digital SAT prep in partnership with College Board — thousands of practice questions and personalized study plans, completely free.
What States Require Standardized Testing for Homeschoolers
About half of U.S. states require some form of assessment for homeschoolers — but assessment doesn’t always mean a standardized test. Knowing that distinction is half the battle. States fall into three tiers. High-regulation states — including New York, Pennsylvania, Oregon, and West Virginia — require annual assessment for all homeschoolers, but even here alternatives often exist that most families never explore. New York, for example, permits families to alternate between a standardized test and a written narrative evaluation. Maine allows portfolio review through a certified teacher. Moderate-regulation states like Florida and North Carolina require assessment under specific conditions but offer portfolio review as a widely used alternative. North Carolina requires an annual nationally normed test, but no minimum score, and results stay on file with the family — they go nowhere. Low-regulation and no-assessment states — including Texas, California, and Illinois — have zero state testing requirements.
Laws change, and local districts sometimes interpret them differently. Christy-Faith strongly advises verifying your state’s current requirements through your state homeschool organization before making any testing decisions based on what you heard on a podcast — including this one. The full breakdown of what states require standardized testing for homeschoolers is linked in the resources section below.
How to Use Testing Strategically — Not Reflexively
The core takeaway from this episode isn’t a test recommendation or a state law summary. It’s a reframe: standardized tests don’t measure your child’s education. They measure how much your child’s education overlaps with what public schools happen to teach at that grade level. Those are two entirely different things, and once you see that distinction clearly, testing becomes a tool you can pick up or put down with intention, rather than a verdict you have to brace for.
Test when you need to catch gaps, when your state requires it, when college is on the horizon, or when you genuinely need an outside reference point. Think twice when your kids are young, when your approach runs on a completely different timeline, or when the results won’t change a single decision you make. And whatever your state requires — always investigate the alternatives before assuming a bubble sheet is your only option. The quote that Christy-Faith leaves her audience with — often attributed to Albert Einstein — captures it well: “Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing it is stupid.” You don’t have to keep using the wrong ruler. But when you do use one, use it strategically.
Resources Mentioned
- Homeschool Laws By State — View state requirements
- BJU Press Online Testing — Iowa Assessments and Stanford 10 online
- Free Quote Notecard — The “fish and tree” quote on a beautiful free printable notecard
- The Christy-Faith List — A free directory of homeschool-friendly businesses and providers
- Thrive Homeschool Community — Christy-Faith’s membership community for homeschool moms
📚 Looking for more free resources? Find all of Christy-Faith’s freebies — including Curriculum Recommendations, Homeschool Style Finder, and Sample Schedules — at christy-faith.com/#freebies
Related Episodes
If this episode resonated with you, you’ll also want to listen to:
- Why Homeschooling High School Isn’t As Scary As It Seems — Everything you need to feel confident homeschooling through high school, including transcripts and credits. Listen here
- The 5 Myths of Homeschooling for High School — Christy-Faith dismantles the most common fears holding families back from homeschooling the high school years. Listen here
- Underemployment, Student Debt, and the Homeschool Advantage — The real-world case for what a homeschool education does for your child’s future. Listen here
Frequently Asked Questions
Which standardized test is best for homeschoolers?
According to Christy-Faith, a homeschool expert with over 20 years of experience in education, the right test depends entirely on what you need it to do. For identifying specific skill gaps, the Iowa Assessments offer the most diagnostic detail. For kids with test anxiety or attention challenges, the untimed Stanford 10 is a better fit. Classically educated students often score higher on the CLT (Classic Learning Test) than on the SAT or ACT because its passages — drawn from Aristotle, C.S. Lewis, and Frederick Douglass — reflect the education they’ve actually received. There is no single best test; the best test is the one that gives your family information you’ll actually use.
What states require standardized testing for homeschoolers?
Christy-Faith explains that roughly half of U.S. states require some form of assessment for homeschoolers, but “assessment” doesn’t always mean a standardized test. High-regulation states like New York, Pennsylvania, Oregon, and West Virginia require annual assessment but often allow alternatives such as portfolio review or written narrative evaluations. Moderate-regulation states like Florida and North Carolina require testing under certain conditions but offer options including portfolio review. Low-regulation states — including Texas, California, and Illinois — have zero state testing requirements. Christy-Faith strongly advises verifying your current state requirements through your state homeschool organization, as laws change.
Do homeschool kids do better on standardized tests?
Yes — research consistently shows that homeschooled students score above the national average on standardized tests. Christy-Faith, who spent years teaching SAT and ACT prep and writing test prep curriculum, points out that homeschool students often enter testing situations with an advantage: strong reading foundations, deep content knowledge, and one-on-one instruction that builds genuine understanding rather than test-taking reflexes. She notes that homeschool families should see this as an asset, particularly for college-bound students as the test-optional wave recedes and schools like MIT, Harvard, and Stanford return to requiring or recommending scores.
When should I start testing my homeschool child?
Christy-Faith recommends against formal standardized testing before age seven or eight. In the early years, children develop at wildly different rates and formal test scores at this age are unreliable indicators of long-term ability — they’re more likely to create anxiety for both parent and child than to provide useful information. Testing begins to earn its place when it can actually inform a decision: identifying gaps in foundational skills before they snowball, fulfilling a state requirement, preparing for college admissions, or getting an outside reference point when objectivity as the teacher-parent gets difficult to maintain.
Is standardized testing required if we homeschool?
Whether standardized testing is required depends entirely on the state. Christy-Faith explains that roughly half of U.S. states require some form of annual assessment for homeschoolers, but many of those states offer alternatives to standardized testing — including portfolio review, written narrative evaluations, or evaluation by a certified teacher. The other half of states have no testing requirements at all, leaving all testing decisions to the family. Christy-Faith advises every homeschool family to verify their state’s current requirements through their state homeschool organization rather than relying on secondhand information, as requirements can and do change.
⭐ Also on The Christy-Faith Show: Episode 92 — Behind the Screen — a real homeschool day at my house. Nobody’s winning awards.
About Christy-Faith
Christy-Faith is a homeschool expert, author, speaker, and the host of The Christy-Faith Show — the podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously. With over 20 years of experience in education, a master’s degree, and a background founding and directing one of the country’s top private learning centers, Christy-Faith has advised everyone from everyday families to A-list celebrities and billionaires on their children’s education. She is the author of Homeschool Rising: Shattering Myths, Finding Courage, and Opting Out of the School System, the founder of the Thrive Homeschool Community, and the creator of the Christy-Faith List — a free directory of homeschool-friendly businesses and providers. A homeschool mom of four, she reaches over 400,000 followers across social media and has built one of the largest and most trusted voices in the homeschool movement.
Listen to the full episode above, and if this was helpful, share it with a homeschool mom who needs to hear it.
