The Hidden Reasons Kids Resist Schoolwork (And What Helps) // Sarah Collins

shop
thrive Homeschool Community
Freebies
search espisode archive

The podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously.

NEW EPISODES drop EVERY THURSDAY

Listen here:

Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Amazon

The Hidden Reasons Kids Resist Schoolwork: An Occupational Therapist on Meltdowns, “I Can’t,” and What Actually Helps

It usually starts with three small words: “I can’t do this.” Sometimes it comes with tears. Sometimes it’s a flat refusal, a meltdown, or a pencil thrown across the room. And before long, a second question creeps in for the mom sitting at the table: Can I really do this?

In this episode of The Christy-Faith Show โ€” the podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously โ€” homeschool expert Christy-Faith, an education and parenting expert with over 20 years of experience, sits down with Sarah Collins, MSOT, OTR/L, a pediatric occupational therapist, homeschool mom, and founder of HomeschoolOT. Together they unpack the hidden reasons kids resist schoolwork, and how an occupational therapy lens helps you find out what is really going on before you treat it as a behavior problem.

Christy-Faith's free homeschool curriculum recommendations
Free Resource
My Curriculum Recommendations

I spill the tea! No paid sponsorship placements! Grab the list, by subject, of the most reputable homeschool programs on the market (in my opinion).

๐Ÿ‘‰ Free Download โ†’

Occupational Therapy for Homeschoolers: Why Every Parent Needs an OT Lens

Many parents assume they only need an occupational therapist when a doctor recommends one. Christy-Faith sees it differently: she believes an occupational therapy lens is useful for parenting, period. Sarah explains that the word “occupation” isn’t about a job. It goes back to Charlotte Mason’s day and simply means how a person occupies their time โ€” everything they need and want to do in a day.

That covers a lot of ground in a homeschool: getting out of bed, eating, handwriting, transitions, and learning itself. When any of those becomes a struggle, an OT comes alongside the family to figure out the why. Only after the why is clear does the plan for support make sense.

BJU Press Homeschool curriculum
Sponsor
BJU Press Homeschool
Need a curriculum that flexes with your family? BJU Press builds biblical worldview and critical thinking into every grade level โ€” with hands-on learning your kids will actually engage with.
๐Ÿ‘‰ View Samples โ†’

When Your Child Says “I Can’t”: The Person, the Environment, or the Task

Sarah’s first step with parents is changing the language. If a child says “I can’t do it” and we answer “Yes, you can,” we’re already arguing with them. If we hear “I can’t do it this way” instead, the conversation turns into problem-solving. From there, she looks at three areas. The person: is it sensory, like a page that looks overwhelming or a noisy room? Is it executive functioning, like not knowing where to start or how to keep going? The environment: Sarah’s own son needed to sit in a specific, well-supported way to build writing endurance, and a crowded page made reading much harder for him. And the task itself: for a three-paragraph assignment, could the child dictate while a parent writes, or use talk-to-text, so the hard part gets broken down?

Christy-Faith shared a real example from her own home. Her 10-year-old daughter, with no diagnosis at all, looked at a co-op writing assignment that wasn’t due for a week and said, “I can’t do this.” Christy-Faith used an occupational therapy technique that took about thirty seconds, and soon her daughter had two paragraphs to show her. Her advice to moms with more than one child is simple: investigate before you compare. A task that was easy for an older sibling may truly be harder for the next child, sometimes for a reason as simple as eye tracking that causes headaches while reading.

Body Signals and Patterns Behind Homeschool Meltdowns

Sarah encourages parents to become a student of their student. Track the patterns: does the struggle show up every day right after lunch? Is it the math, or the time of day? Look at what happens before, during, and after a hard moment, especially in relation to food, water, movement, and time outside. Often a mom’s schedule decides when the hard work happens, even if that’s not when the child is at their best.

Kids often can’t name what their bodies are telling them, but parents can see the clues: fast breathing, slouching, raised shoulders, or rocking back in a chair. Sarah suggests naming what you notice โ€” “I’m noticing your shoulders are really high” โ€” and wondering together what might help, like going on a walk. Christy-Faith adds that she has worked for years to give her kids language for their feelings, sometimes pulling up a feelings chart after a hard day. The payoff: her daughters now come to her saying, “I’m dysregulated, and I don’t know why,” and ask for help instead of lashing out.

Resistance doesn’t always look like a battle, either. Sarah points out that the child who screams “I’m not doing it” and the child who spins, jumps, and gets silly are often doing the same thing: avoiding the task. One is just more acceptable to the adults around them than the other.

CTC Math online homeschool math program
Sponsor
CTC Math
Struggling with math? CTC Math adapts to your child’s level and teaches, grades, and tests for you โ€” so you can stop stressing. Get 50% off for homeschool families.
๐Ÿ‘‰ Free Trial โ†’
๐Ÿ‘‰ Get 50% Off โ†’

Fear-Based Parenting vs. Being Your Child’s Teammate

Some parents worry that accommodations are just coddling โ€” that if a child dictates an essay while a parent types, they’ll never learn. Christy-Faith wanted to speak to that with both grace and truth: without ignoring sin, she believes the behavior is very often a child communicating a breakdown, and treating it only as a behavior problem can do real harm to families. Sarah explains that much of this comes from fear, and that most of that fear comes from wanting the best for our kids. Every developmental milestone is based on a norm, which means a bell curve and a range. Not every child fits exactly into the box.

When fear drives us, Sarah says, support comes out as accusation: “You should be able to do this by now.” Instead, parents can be their child’s biggest supporter and teammate, meeting them where they are today. That builds kids who know how to advocate for themselves and solve problems later in life. As Christy-Faith put it, being an accuser is not being a helper. When she gets dysregulated with her own kids, she can almost always trace it back to fear, and she goes back and apologizes.

Designing a Homeschool Learning Space Around Sensory Needs

What would kids design if they could build their own learning space? When Sarah asked her children, the answers boiled down to options: a calm, quiet space one day, room to bounce another day, and white noise another day. Christy-Faith noticed her own kids already choose different spots for different subjects โ€” reading on her bed, math at the dining room table with graph paper, and Bible in the living room. Both moms admit they started with a beautiful school room (Sarah even had a flag for the Pledge of Allegiance), and both say that’s fine. It just may not be where the learning ends up happening.

The freedom to move is one of homeschooling’s gifts. Sarah’s family does spelling on the trampoline. But for handwriting, kids need real support. Her youngest used to sit on the bottom step so his ankles, knees, and hips were at 90 degrees with his back supported, with a slanted lap desk on his lap. Christy-Faith also reminds parents that a child’s attention span on an assigned task is different from a chosen task. A child who can play Minecraft for hours is not necessarily ready to do spelling for hours.

LearningRx cognitive skills training
Sponsor
LearningRx
Is your child struggling with attention, memory, reading, writing, or math? LearningRx is a proven program backed by 35 years of research, designed to strengthen cognitive skills so your child can think faster, learn more easily, and perform at their best โ€” including real, long-term help with ADHD and dyslexia. Use code HOME50 for $50 off your assessment.
๐Ÿ‘‰ Get $50 Off Your Cognitive Skills Assessment โ†’

The Just Right Challenge: Adjusting Without Lowering the Bar

How does a mom make changes without simply making things easier? Sarah uses two approaches from occupational therapy together. The top-down approach adapts the task itself so the child can do it now. The bottom-up approach builds the underlying skills the child needs. The goal is for the two to meet in the middle: lower the expectation for now, not the bar, while the skills grow. As skills build, the supports are slowly loosened, keeping the child at what OTs call the “just right challenge.”

Christy-Faith was so struck by this explanation that she told listeners to rewind and play it three times. It matches what she saw when helping kids with executive functioning and long-term projects: break the work into the next small step, and if that step is still too big, break it down again. A child can do the next one thing once you find the right-sized next one thing.

You Don’t Have to Do This Alone

Sarah has been in the hard place herself. Even as an OT, she worried that her son’s struggles to read would last forever. Recently, on a drive to his hockey academy, he asked her, “Mom, when did I learn to read?” She couldn’t remember the exact moment it clicked โ€” only that it was hard for a long time, and that he went on to exceed her expectations. She also shared how pride kept her trying to do it all alone until she realized she needed support too, often from the homeschool parents around her.

Christy-Faith pushed back on the idea that choosing homeschooling means you’re on your own. Pulling a child out of school doesn’t make special needs disappear, and it doesn’t make mom Wonder Woman. Even with her career in education, she missed that her son’s handwriting struggles were tied to eye tracking. Sarah found it in a consultation. Sarah works directly with kids in Pennsylvania and offers one-on-one homeschool consultations for families outside Pennsylvania, and she also mentors moms during monthly office hours inside Thrive Homeschool Community. Whether help comes from a professional, your church, or a friend in your homeschool community, it’s okay to build a team.

โญ New to Homeschooling? Start with Episode 101 โ€” the New Homeschooler Series is the best place to begin.

Resources Mentioned

๐Ÿ“š Looking for more free resources? Find all of Christy-Faith’s freebies โ€” including Curriculum Recommendations, Homeschool Style Finder, and Sample Schedules โ€” at christy-faith.com/#freebies

Related Episodes

If this episode resonated with you, you’ll also want to listen to:

  • Ep. 137 โ€” How to Homeschool Pre-K to 2nd Grade Without Constant Battles (Smooth Days Part 1) โ€” Attention span by age, co-regulation, and meltdowns in the early years โ€” the series Christy-Faith mentions in this episode. Listen here
  • Ep. 138 โ€” Elementary Homeschooling: How Much Independence? (Smooth Days Part 2) โ€” Math meltdowns, the “they knew it yesterday” problem, and keeping high standards while staying on your child’s side. Listen here
  • Ep. 139 โ€” Teen Homeschooling: How to Build Independence Without Losing Connection (Smooth Days Part 3) โ€” The teen brain, procrastination, executive function, and how to stop being the schedule police. Listen here

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my child say “I can’t” when doing schoolwork?

According to Christy-Faith, a homeschool expert with over 20 years of experience in education, “I can’t” is usually a sign that something is breaking down, not simple defiance. In this episode, pediatric occupational therapist Sarah Collins suggests hearing it as “I can’t do it this way.” The child may be overwhelmed by how big the task looks, distracted by noise, unsure where to start, or physically uncomfortable. When parents stop arguing with “Yes, you can,” they can start solving the problem together.

How can I tell if my child’s resistance is a behavior problem or something else?

Christy-Faith, a homeschool expert with over 20 years of experience in education, encourages parents to investigate before calling resistance a behavior problem. Sarah Collins recommends tracking patterns: what time of day the struggle shows up, and what happened right before it, including food, water, movement, and time outside. Body language helps too, like fast breathing, slouching, raised shoulders, or rocking in a chair. Silliness, stalling, and meltdowns can all be the same avoidance showing up in different ways.

What does an occupational therapist look at when a child struggles with schoolwork?

According to pediatric occupational therapist Sarah Collins, an OT looks at three areas: the person, the environment, and the task. The person includes things like sensory processing and executive functioning, such as knowing where to start or how to keep going. The environment includes seating and how much is on the page. The task is the assignment itself, which can often be broken down or adapted. Homeschool expert Christy-Faith believes this lens is useful for every parent, not only families who have been referred to an OT.

How can I adjust schoolwork without lowering expectations?

Sarah Collins describes using a top-down and a bottom-up approach together. Top-down means adapting the task so the child can do it now, like letting them dictate while a parent writes. Bottom-up means building the underlying skills at the same time. As the skills grow, the supports are slowly removed, keeping the child at the “just right challenge.” Christy-Faith, a homeschool expert with over 20 years of experience, adds that breaking big projects into the next small step is one of the most effective tools she has used with families.

How do I set up a homeschool learning space that works for my child?

According to Christy-Faith, a homeschool expert and homeschool mom of four, many kids naturally choose different spots for different subjects, like reading on a bed and math at the dining room table. Sarah Collins recommends giving kids options to move and meet their sensory needs, while also offering a supported spot for handwriting, with feet flat, back supported, and ankles, knees, and hips at about 90 degrees. A beautiful school room is fine, but flexibility usually serves kids best.

Summit Healthshare health sharing plans
Sponsor
Summit Healthshare
Evaluations and specialist visits add up fast. Summit Healthshare saves homeschool families 40โ€“60% vs. traditional insurance โ€” see any doctor, no networks, no permission slips.
๐Ÿ‘‰ View Health Plans & Savings โ†’

About Our Guest

Sarah Collins, MSOT, OTR/L is a pediatric occupational therapist, homeschool mom, and founder of HomeschoolOT. She helps families understand the skills behind learning, including executive functioning, sensory processing, and handwriting, so they can better support their children at home. Sarah is also the host of The OT is IN podcast, where she brings an occupational therapy lens to the everyday challenges of homeschooling.

๐Ÿ‘‰ homeschoolot.com
Instagram ยท Facebook ยท LinkedIn ยท TikTok ยท YouTube

About Christy-Faith

Christy-Faith is a homeschool expert, author, speaker, and the host of The Christy-Faith Show โ€” the podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously. With over 20 years of experience in education, a master’s degree, and a background founding and directing one of the country’s top private learning centers, Christy-Faith has advised everyone from everyday families to A-list celebrities and billionaires on their children’s education. She is the author of Homeschool Rising: Shattering Myths, Finding Courage, and Opting Out of the School System, the founder of the Thrive Homeschool Community, and the creator of the Christy-Faith List โ€” a free directory of homeschool-friendly businesses and providers. A homeschool mom of four, she reaches over 400,000 followers across social media and has built one of the largest and most trusted voices in the homeschool movement.

Listen to the full episode above, and if this was helpful, share it with a homeschool mom who needs to hear it.