Listen here:
Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Amazon
AI and Homeschooling: How to Use ChatGPT and Other AI Tools Without Hurting Your Child’s Learning
“Can I just use AI for this, Mom?” If you’ve heard that question in your homeschool, you’re not alone. AI tools like ChatGPT are showing up everywhere, and they’re moving faster than most of us feel ready for. Should our kids be using them? Should we? And how do we keep a helpful tool from quietly doing our children’s thinking for them?
In this episode of The Christy-Faith Show, homeschool expert Christy-Faith sits down with her friend Nancy Manos, host of the AI and Your Homeschool Podcast and a homeschool leader for more than 20 years. Together they define what AI really is, name the concerns every parent should know about, and share practical, faith-centered wisdom on AI and homeschooling β without fear and without blind enthusiasm.
What AI Can Do β and What It Can’t Replace
Nancy starts by defining terms. When most of us say “AI,” we mean large language models like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Grok. These tools are trained on huge amounts of data to recognize patterns and generate responses β basically a very sophisticated predictive text machine. They can organize information, help you brainstorm, plan, summarize, write code, and create images. What makes them different is that they can sound human. But sounding human doesn’t make them human, and they don’t have wisdom, beliefs, judgment, or values. They can also be confidently wrong.
From a Christian perspective on AI, Nancy draws a clear line: AI cannot have a real human relationship, and it cannot give you spiritual guidance β even when it tries. (Some users have had a chatbot tell them, “I’m praying for you.”) Nancy shares a framework from author Misty Phillip: put AI in its proper place. Let computers do computer things, and let humans do human things.
Kids and AI: Neither Fear nor Blind Enthusiasm
How do we raise children wisely when AI is becoming more powerful every month? Nancy’s answer: neither extreme serves our kids well. Fear doesn’t help, and neither does adopting every new, shiny tool just because everyone else is. The landscape has changed, but our job as parents hasn’t β we’re still discipling our children, forming their character, and helping them grow. We can’t bury our heads in the sand, because AI isn’t going anywhere. We just need to stay engaged and use discernment.
Christy-Faith, a trained historian, brings a long view. New technology β from the Gutenberg press to the Industrial Revolution β doesn’t automatically make life easier. She shares how building an AI assistant for her own work actually made her deadlines faster and her days more rushed. Her takeaway: humans bring their own “me problems” to every new technology, so we need to stay in touch with our own humanity and our spiritual walk as we use these tools.
The Critical Thinking Skills Kids Need for an AI Future
We can’t even name many of the jobs our kids will have ten years from now. So what should we be teaching? Nancy says kids need a solid base of knowledge, because when an AI tool hands them an answer, they need to be able to ask: Is this true? How do I know? Where do I go to check? That takes research skills, critical thinking skills, strong relationships, and perseverance.
Technology removes friction β and sometimes that friction is exactly what learning needs. Nancy compares learning to a muscle: if you remove the struggle, the muscle doesn’t get built. If ChatGPT writes the essay, your child hasn’t learned anything, even if they read it five times. Christy-Faith adds that so much of writing is thinking, and that today’s adults came into the age of AI with those skills already in place. Our kids won’t, unless we protect the work that builds them.
When Your Child Asks, “Can I Just Use AI for This?”
Christy-Faith’s son asks this all the time, and she has a simple filter: Is this going to replace his thinking? If it is, she’s cautious or says no. If the learning is already done, AI can be a great way to build technology skills. At the end of one school year, her son gathered all the facts for his cultural geography presentation himself, then used an AI tool to turn them into a song β and picked the pictures to go with it. She also has her kids use tools like Canva to build design skills in place of a traditional essay.
Nancy puts it even more simply: what is the purpose of the assignment? If the purpose is to learn a skill, don’t use technology to bypass that skill.
AI Concerns Every Parent Should Know: Misinformation, Privacy, and Flattery
AI doesn’t serve up facts β it serves up a reasonable-sounding response. Nancy shares the story of a podcast guest who asked an AI tool for homeschool research. It returned the name of a study, a link, and statistics that sounded right in line with real research from Dr. Brian Ray and the National Home Education Research Institute. When he went looking, the study didn’t exist. Christy-Faith’s habit: ask for links, then actually click them and check.
On privacy, Nancy recommends treating AI tools like email, texts, or social media: imagine anything you type could be shown on a stadium screen in front of a million people. And watch out for flattery. Unless you set it up otherwise, AI tends to tell you what you want to hear β your questions are brilliant, your ideas are the best. Christy-Faith’s son has a word for it: “glazing.” Nancy suggests adjusting your settings to ask for direct answers without the flattery.
How Homeschool Moms Can Use AI (Without Losing What Matters)
There are so many ways AI can help moms behind the scenes. Nancy suggests using it to find field trips that match what you’re studying, to find a different way to explain a concept your child is stuck on, to create age-appropriate activities so all your kids can study ancient Egypt together, to come up with ideas that keep little ones busy, or to write discussion questions for the drive home from a play. Christy-Faith uses AI to brainstorm affordable, engaging co-op projects for her US history class β and even to plan a two-day theme park trip.
But there’s a trade-off. Christy-Faith once used AI to print a decimals lesson for her fifth grader, who came back thirty minutes later understanding the concept. It worked β but she wondered, “Did I just cheat?” They didn’t work through it together, and that time together had value. Nancy agrees: any tool that makes things easier also has the potential to create a deficit. And you don’t have to master every tool. The tools change constantly, so take the pressure off β you’re learning alongside your kids.
Why Homeschool Families Have the Advantage in the Age of AI
Christy-Faith believes homeschoolers have an edge because homeschooling can treat education as skills, not just content. Kids will probably never use long division as adults β but they will use the working memory, multistep problem solving, and logical reasoning it builds. Nancy adds that homeschool families have time. When something online starts affecting a child negatively, a parent can notice and pivot quickly, making decisions for their unique children rather than a whole classroom.
Nancy’s advice for families today: eat dinner together with no screens, play board games, and teach real-life skills side by side β from chopping vegetables to coding. Christy-Faith encourages moms to ask the “why” behind every assignment, and to let kids sit in the healthy frustration of learning. As Nancy puts it, the question of AI doesn’t change the goal: we’re still raising kind, compassionate, thoughtful people with good character.
β New to Homeschooling? Start with Episode 101 β the New Homeschooler Series is the best place to begin.
Resources Mentioned
- AI and Your Homeschool Podcast β Nancy Manos’s podcast for parents navigating AI and technology
- Free Family Discussion Guide β Nancy’s free guide with questions for parents, teens, and the whole family
- The Trojan Horse of the Digital Age: Why Christians Must Discern AI β book by Misty Phillip
- The Christy-Faith List β Find homeschool-friendly businesses and providers
- Thrive Homeschool Community β Christy-Faith’s membership community for homeschool moms
π Looking for more free resources? Find all of Christy-Faith’s freebies β including Curriculum Recommendations, Homeschool Style Finder, and Sample Schedules β at christy-faith.com/#freebies
Related Episodes
If this episode resonated with you, you’ll also want to listen to:
- How to Reduce Screen Time for Kids β Christy-Faith shares what she learned teaching digital literacy to high schoolers, plus a simple framework for evaluating screen time in your home. Listen here
- Are Schools Killing a Love of Learning? β Why a child’s natural love of learning is worth protecting. Listen here
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it okay for homeschool kids to use AI like ChatGPT for schoolwork?
According to homeschool expert Christy-Faith, it depends on the purpose of the assignment. When her kids ask, “Can I just use AI for this?” she asks whether the tool will replace their thinking β and if it will, the answer is usually no. Her guest Nancy Manos adds a simple rule: if the purpose of the assignment is to learn a skill, don’t use technology to bypass that skill. AI can be a good fit for building technology skills after the real learning is done.
What can AI do well, and what can’t it replace?
On The Christy-Faith Show, Nancy Manos explains that AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini are large language models β essentially sophisticated predictive text β that can organize information, brainstorm, plan, summarize, write code, and create images. What AI cannot do is have a real human relationship or give true spiritual guidance, even when it sounds human. Christy-Faith and Nancy agree that families should put AI in its proper place: let computers do computer things and let humans do human things.
How can homeschool moms use AI without hurting learning?
According to Christy-Faith, AI works best as a planning and brainstorming partner for mom rather than a shortcut for kids. Ideas from the episode include finding field trips that match what you’re studying, finding a new way to explain a concept your child is stuck on, creating age-appropriate activities so siblings can learn the same topic together, and writing discussion questions for the drive home from a play. Christy-Faith also notes the trade-off: anything that makes a task easier can create a deficit, so it’s worth asking what you might be giving up.
What skills do kids need to be ready for a future shaped by AI?
Christy-Faith points out that we can’t even name many of the jobs our kids will have in ten years, so the focus should be on lasting skills. In this episode, Nancy Manos names a solid base of knowledge, research skills, critical thinking, strong communication, perseverance, and the ability to check whether an AI answer is true. Both agree that learning is like a muscle β when technology removes the struggle, the muscle doesn’t get built.
Why do homeschool families have an advantage in the age of AI?
According to Christy-Faith, homeschoolers can treat education as skill-building instead of just content, which prepares kids to think for themselves. Nancy Manos adds that homeschool families have time with their kids, so parents can notice quickly when technology is affecting a child negatively and pivot faster than a classroom can. Homeschooling also makes room for the human things AI can’t replace β dinner conversations, board games, hands-on skills, and learning side by side.
About Our Guest
Nancy Manos homeschooled her two daughters from preschool through high school and has served in homeschool leadership for more than 20 years. She is passionate about encouraging and equipping parents in the homeschool adventure. Nancy hosts the AI and Your Homeschool Podcast, where she helps parents raise children wisely and with discernment in a world of rapidly changing technology.
π nancymanos.com
About Christy-Faith
Christy-Faith is a homeschool expert, author, speaker, and the host of The Christy-Faith Showβthe podcast for homeschool moms who take their craft seriously. With over 20 years of experience in education, a master’s degree, and a background founding and directing one of the country’s top private learning centers, Christy-Faith has advised everyone from everyday families to A-list celebrities and billionaires on their children’s education. She is the author of Homeschool Rising: Shattering Myths, Finding Courage, and Opting Out of the School System, the founder of the Thrive Homeschool Community, and the creator of the Christy-Faith Listβa free directory of homeschool-friendly businesses and providers. A homeschool mom of four, she reaches over 400,000 followers across social media and has built one of the largest and most trusted voices in the homeschool movement.
Listen to the full episode above, and if this was helpful, share it with a homeschool mom who needs to hear it.
